How politics destroyed ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan’s career and set back India’s space program

عدد المشاهدات 1 188 676
99% 27 000 1

A shameful episode of petty politics destroyed the life and career of the brilliant ISRO scientist, Nambi Narayanan and set back India’s space program by nearly a decade. 25 years after he was set free, the Supreme Court finally named 18 police officers, all now retired, for their role in framing Nambi.

Join us on
Discord: discord.gg/PKF5AmDde5
Instagram: @gobisbo
Facebook: Bisbo
Twitter: @Bisboworld


Times of India
Isro espionage case: FIR against 18 ex-cops; June 25, 2021
Justice Jain submits report on police role in framing scientist in ISRO spy case; Dhananjay Mahapatra; April 5, 2021
No rocket science, this: The framing of Nambi Narayanan may have involved three conspiracies in one; Arun Ram; September 14, 2018

The Tribune
1994 ISRO spy scandal: Justice DK Jain Committee submits report on allegations against Kerala police officers; April 3, 2021

The Leaflet
SC to hear next week Centre’s application to accept Justice DK Jain committee report on ISRO scientist espionage case; April 5, 2021

India Today
Kerala: Key questions about spy scandal remain unanswered a month after spy ring exposed; M G Radhakrishnan; November 30, 1999
Indian intelligence agencies feud, work at cross-purposes bringing embarrassment; Shekhar Gupta; January 31, 1995

‘Give us any Muslim name’: How authorities tried to build a false spy case against Nambi Narayanan; Nambi Narayanan & Arun Ram; September 15, 2018.

The Wire
Here's the real story of Isro 'spy' case that rocked the nation in the 1990s; Manoj Joshi;
September 16, 2018.

Indian Express
Fake ISRO spy case: The seven characters of the false espionage story; September 19, 2018.

The Print
The fake ‘spy thriller’ that cost Nambi Narayanan his career, life savings and self-esteem; Shekhar Gupta; September 14, 2018.
ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan says Kalam wanted him to give up fight, but he refused; Rohini Swamy; September 16, 2018.
Justice for ISRO’s Nambi Narayanan: How IB, CBI, courts tangled in spy case, ruined India's interest; Shekhar Gupta; Aug 13, 2020.

BBC News
Nambi Narayanan: The fake spy scandal that blew up a rocket scientist’s career; Soutik Biswas; January 27, 2020.

Youth Ki Awaz
S. Nambi Narayanan: A Patriot Turned Into A Traitor By A Broken System; Shubham Singla; April 10, 2021.

The Week
ISRO 'fake' espionage case: SC orders CBI probe into arrest of Nambi Narayanan; April 15, 2021.

Hindustan Times
The 1994 espionage case that led to Isro scientist Nambi Narayanan's arrest; Shivani Kumar; April 16, 2021.

The Hindu
Nambi Narayanan | The battles of a space dreamer; Tiki Rajwi; April 17, 2021.

How Nambi Narayanan was framed in a fake Spy Case?; Neeraj Mahajan

تم نشره في





تحميل فيديوهات:

جار تحميل الرابط.....

اضف إليه:

بلدي قائمة التشغيل
سأشاهده لاحقا
تعليقات 2 389
Saurabh Pandey
Saurabh Pandey سنوات قبل
Everyone wants to criticize police,media without criticizing themselves. If tomorrow a case of same nature comes out then we will be the first person to call the accused a traitor or spy. Media knows public's emotion very well and thats why they play with it very easily. If you disagree then just think about Riya Chakraborty case and how public and media unleashed hell on her.
kuttu babu
kuttu babu أشهر قبل
@Jayanth Reddy nambi lost this hos years.... Who is responsible for this... Just giving a money is not enough..... He not a common mam... He is a great scientist who invented vikas engine remember that...
Muttusamy Lingam
Muttusamy Lingam أشهر قبل
Simplifying Food by Mary Damian
Idli powder :- ar-vids.com/video/%D9%81%D9%8A%D8%AF%D9%8A%D9%88-N1hUlvfL34k.html
sriram sankar
sriram sankar أشهر قبل
Totally agreed. :( But still man, Nambi Narayanan. When everyone knew his charecter. Tch. Its such a shame. Its easy to really shout now. Then when he was beaten and given the 3rd. Oh Rama. True to it, VIKAS never failed. Also one tech which never existed, how can he sell it. Its just very very sad and its a shame. Its a blot on our country and our Space Race, delayed by 20 years. Ps- footnote whosoever hates Nambi sir still, there is proof and he is also acquitted. Nambi in Tamizh is trust. A guy named nambi, why would he cheat? 🤦‍♂️😭❤️🔥🇮🇳 JAI HIND 🇮🇳
rajiv shah
rajiv shah أشهر قبل
I’m sorry but it’s very clear of false accusations by the kerala police . You obviously asked for a pardon kasab the terrorist who killed innocent civilians
Deepa Kulkarni
Deepa Kulkarni سنوات قبل
Poor Nambi didn't accept job in NASA to serve his homeland and he got this for his patriotism. Shame.
Siby Mathews
Siby Mathews أشهر قبل
What great hard work? What about the other thousands of Scientists in ISRO, were they playing chess all the time?
Jim أشهر قبل
That's exactly what I felt. Such a shame. So much pain to all the great hardwork
Siby Mathews
Siby Mathews أشهر قبل
@D Gillies Mr.Gillies, please tell us, in Nambi case, who gave bribe, and how much, to whom? Was it to State Police Chief of Kerala?
Gokul Raj
Gokul Raj أشهر قبل
@Siby Mathews I think that Sasikumar has some problems in potraying Nambi as a hero in the movie... For any movie the lead character will be glorified like that only. For example in MS Dhoni movie, Dhoni's character is glorified more than other players, but that doesn't mean that other Indian cricketers are insignificant. That Sasikumar and the people supporting him should understand this.
D Gillies
D Gillies أشهر قبل
Let this video be a lesson for India. As my closest born-and-raised-in-India EE-engineer friend (whose father owned a factory in India) says, "India is full of corruption, especially police corruption!" With a small bribe these police were able to destroy India's leading rocket program and leading scientist! Nambi was on the verge of earning BILLIONs of dollars in the satellite-launch business - for India! So this is why tech workers are always leaving India! If India can't protect its best and brightest people, why stay there? Why not go someplace where your work is respected and you can work in peace? Someplace else! This injustice will continue until India reforms its police & judicial systems! Just delayed 25 years is justice denied! I say this in the hopes that constructive criticism will help India!
Nayan Patel
Nayan Patel 27 أيام قبل
Thank you R Madhavan for making "Rocketry: The Nambi Effect" and bringing the story of such a great scientist to the world and teaching a huge lesson to the nation.
Omy & Sea
Omy & Sea 2 أشهر قبل
Lesson learnt : Never believe if someone is guilty until proven ! And never accuse anyone
Rahul Janghel
Rahul Janghel 2 أشهر قبل
I watched this video again as soon as I saw the movie "Rocketry - The Nambi Effet" on Amazon Prime. Sir Nambi, we are sorry for all the difficulty you have faced. I salute your patriotism and your fight for the truth. You are a real gem and we are proud of you. 🙏
Umang Shukla
Umang Shukla 2 أشهر قبل
Thank you for making a detailed video on this. 🙏🏻 Recently I saw R Madhavn interview in which he talk about Nabmi sir. One sentence that shook me was, "Although justice is delivered, award and compensation was given but try and search for my name in google, top results include all false accusations against me, and people still believe them". Some important take from this case:- 1. Politics have precedence over anything in this country. 2. Lack of awareness leads to misinformation injected in the grapevine of our society. 3. If a budding scientist took this as an example he will never imagine his career in #ISRO resulting in another channel for brain drain 4. Rather than posthumously correcting our mistake, we should acknowledge our mistake and deliver the justice Nambi sir expects and deserves. A huge thank you for Bisbo 🙏🏻
Prakash M.S
Prakash M.S سنوات قبل
By the way, the guy who made up this story to topple the Kerala government become the 23rd Defence Minister of India. (A. K. Antony)
D Gillies
D Gillies أشهر قبل
Let this video be a lesson for India. As my closest born-and-raised-in-India EE-engineer friend (whose father owned a factory in India) says, "India is full of corruption, especially police corruption!" With a small bribe these police were able to destroy India's leading rocket program and leading scientist! Nambi was on the verge of earning BILLIONs of dollars in the satellite-launch business - for India! So this is why tech workers are always leaving India! If India can't protect it's best and brightest people, why stay there? Why not go someplace where your work is respected and you can work in peace? Someplace else! This injustice will continue until India reforms its police & judicial systems! Just delayed 25 years is justice denied! I say this in the hopes that constructive criticism will help India!
anishglx أشهر قبل
@Daveed Amos what were the motivations for those RAW officers to stoop that level
Lord V
Lord V أشهر قبل
Congress is a traitor for India
Narayan Acharya
Narayan Acharya أشهر قبل
If this scientist was allowed to work on his full potential, I wonder how many Elon Musk he would be walking in the streets of India.
anishglx أشهر قبل
Kerala Gov of CM Karunakaran?
koustubh132 سنوات قبل
Very sad indeed. It really shows how helpless the common people are against administrative harassment should they falsely try to frame somebody ( unless he or she has very powerful connections ). Feel very sorry for the plight of such a talented son of India.
Sunny Soni
Sunny Soni 2 أشهر قبل
No amount of money offered to Nambi in compensation can get the years of missed progress back. Filling cases against police officers after 26 years, who now must be at good ranks makes ZERO sense but still fine. May the truth prevail.
Menda Chinnappanna
Menda Chinnappanna 2 أشهر قبل
This money recovered from retired police officers and chief Minister of that time, the Court must give orders
Sourav kumar
Sourav kumar سنوات قبل
I am science student but I never hear about him. He decided to serve his motherland and tourtured for 25 years. What kind of problems he and his family had face on those periods Hope this never happen again
Raghu Iyer
Raghu Iyer سنوات قبل
Because of corrupted politicians, good souls like him loses their lives. Apart from personal loss for those innocent people, it is a great loss for our country also.
Vineeth :⁠-⁠)
Vineeth :⁠-⁠) سنوات قبل
Shame on politics and police who destroyed the career of great scientist... This incident pushed back indian rocket science 14 years.. Many successful missions like chandrayan were supposed to launch 14 years ago, If nambi narayanan's cryogenic technology was done successfully without any political interruptions ........ ______________________❤️___________ Edit :- Thank you all for 1k+ likes And 49+ replies ❤️❤️❤️ ______________________❤️___________
D Gillies
D Gillies أشهر قبل
Let this video be a lesson for India. As my closest born-and-raised-in-India EE-engineer friend (whose father owned a factory in India) says, "India is full of corruption, especially police corruption!" With a small bribe these police were able to destroy India's leading rocket program and leading scientist! Nambi was on the verge of earning BILLIONs of dollars in the satellite-launch business - for India! So this is why tech workers are always leaving India! If India can't protect its best and brightest people, why stay there? Why not go someplace where your work is respected and you can work in peace? Someplace else! This injustice will continue until India reforms its police & judicial systems! Just delayed 25 years is justice denied! I say this in the hopes that constructive criticism will help India!
anishglx أشهر قبل
@Vansh Shetty Arguing with Idiots like JMT ...is like playing chess with Pigeon rest...you know ..
Simplifying Food by Mary Damian
Idli powder :- ar-vids.com/video/%D9%81%D9%8A%D8%AF%D9%8A%D9%88-N1hUlvfL34k.html
Raju Patnaik
Raju Patnaik أشهر قبل
Vineeth Reddy, have you and others ever asked why the PV Narasimha govt. during that time kept quiet when Nambi Sir was in Jail for 50 yrs? Why CBI was told only to investigate if the accusation of him being a Pakistani Spy is true or not but not to catch the Conspirators against Nambi Sir?
TH G أشهر قبل
We should strong stratégie to avoid this. Our scientists work for nation. Police and others who created problem to Nambi, should screwed under their ass and hang them. I will do it in future if anyone screws our nation even if it is politician. Strong action safe life to our nation. What do you think?
Bhavani Kumar
Bhavani Kumar أشهر قبل
Great video explaining the case to the layman. Congratulations. As a citizen I apologise to Mr Nambi for all torture and evil he had to undergo.
P.V. Chandrasekharan
P.V. Chandrasekharan 2 أشهر قبل
Heart breaking episode and shame on India’s investigating agencies!
Sean Ras
Sean Ras 2 أشهر قبل
The persons who laid the false allegation should be identified and given capital punishment. India is being ruined for political ambition.
Manu samy
Manu samy 3 أشهر قبل
The mental agony of his wife and daughter during those custody period couldn't be imagined.
Sachin Jambhulkar
Sachin Jambhulkar سنوات قبل
Once again politics has choosen its prey and demolished larger scientific interest of the country. It's disheartening and beyond imagination how Nambi's family have suffered all this time. A justice delayed, is equal to Justice Denied!!! All appreciation for Bisbo team for putting across through very clear animation and lucid script
Utkarsh Goel
Utkarsh Goel 24 أيام قبل
@Ayush Kumar Pandey lol what about the 10+ scientists mysteriously killed in 2019?
Raju Patnaik
Raju Patnaik أشهر قبل
Sachin, have you and others ever asked why the PV Narasimha govt. during that time kept quiet when Nambi Sir was in Jail for 50 yrs? Why CBI was told only to investigate if the accusation of him being a Pakistani Spy is true or not but not to catch the Conspirators against Nambi Sir?
Praveen Dhanasekar
Praveen Dhanasekar 2 أشهر قبل
Our justice system gives judgement not justices...it's heartbreaking to see many people serve sentence and then realised innocent
joshua john
joshua john سنوات قبل
Lol someone's a bot
Ayush Kumar Pandey
Ayush Kumar Pandey سنوات قبل
What else do you expect from congress and communists. They have always been anti national, and will.always remain the same
Bindu Reddy
Bindu Reddy 2 أشهر قبل
Justice must prevail to Nambi sir! Those who are the reason for destroying his career should be sentenced, in order to prevent any similar intentional acts in future.
Just Forfun9140
Just Forfun9140 2 أشهر قبل
Justice system need reforms: 1. Detainees should treated as innocent until proven guilty by courts. 2. Police should be prohibited from beating or mistreating detainees guilty or not. 3. In this video, the police officer who made moves on the detained woman for her favors, what happened to him?
temporary email
temporary email 2 أشهر قبل
What a sad feeling to know that this is what you get when you truly serve your country despite being offered a position at NASA. !!
Alyssya Jhons
Alyssya Jhons سنوات قبل
Indian politics is far away from that of New Zealand's .. who has set high examples of how a government must run.. people compare countries by size and say that nz is a tiny piece of paper in front of India, but look at the politics here and there, india is full of fights for power while in nz its as calm as a park full of butterflies
Johan Shibu Mathew
Johan Shibu Mathew سنوات قبل
Just imagine what ISRO could have done if we had Nambi Narayan's knowledge with us for 27 years?
Linent Gaming
Linent Gaming 3 أيام قبل
space x screwed like BIG TIME
Siby Mathews
Siby Mathews أشهر قبل
Mr.SA, if you know everything, why don't you reveal it?
S A أشهر قبل
@Siby Mathews better not to answer a man acting asleep like you. You know the whole scenario don't you. Those who scored political brownie points and eventually came to the thorn, their papparazi stooges....and all the allied stakeholders
Siby Mathews
Siby Mathews أشهر قبل
Hey Mr.SA, you are talking rubbish, when Nambi was arrested, Chief Minister of Kerala was Mr.Karunakaran. Was he Anti Hindu?
S A أشهر قبل
@Siby Mathews yaya even if our country rots and suffers it's only important for us to strengthen our religion....Is it not poor laity...Amen
dhyxn سنوات قبل
Added to the tale of " How my Kerala government's immaturity deprived our nation off achieving something huge."
VKM Pilgrim
VKM Pilgrim سنوات قبل
Well done....a much wanted video that can add to what ever little justice was given. I hope all those who conspired to build this fabrication costing many lives rot in prison
Kkokonad Ggupta
Kkokonad Ggupta 2 أشهر قبل
One of the most heartbreaking incident.. Remember our briliant scientists and scholars go abroad in foreign and settle NASA.. because sometimes they don't get chance in our country Our country is best, but somehow politics is drawing us back...
venkat chinni
venkat chinni 2 أشهر قبل
Imagining the life of Nambi Narayanan going through such a pain and all his life dreams shattered. Just think how many motivated people in India lost interest in achieving something.
Ev M
Ev M سنوات قبل
Even in Kerala, Nambi case is such a confusing conspiracy.. 🙏Thanks to this channel we finally got the full unfiltered picture literally. America does not let anyone grow.. their dirty politics with help of local goons proven again. The Smart West made profit we again suffer losses.
Salu S Kumar
Salu S Kumar سنوات قبل
Such scientists are our nations asset....It's highly unfortunate that a very brilliant scientist like him who even refused a job in Nasa had to undergo all this....This itself proves that he loves his country more and how can such a guy do this....if his intention was money , with his skill set and knowledge would have never came back to work for the country....Hope our stupid politicians realise the worth of people like these. No matter how much you pay him after all this as compensation, these things he had to undergo that too being innocent is just beyond words..... Happy that ultimately he fought and proved himself.
Devidas 2 أشهر قبل
The Indian Constitution has strictly separated out executive power and vested it by Art 52(1) and Art 154(1) in identified authorities. Nehru destroyed by aping Westminster. The Nambi Narayanan case and its consequences are a consequence.
Amit Amin
Amit Amin سنوات قبل
Thanks to current Central n Kerala goverment for respecting n reconzing efforts of great man....Good work by channel.
Homo Sapien
Homo Sapien سنوات قبل
Being a pakistani nd a physics enthusiast , my heart is deep in sorrow. When will india nd pakistan start to honor nd respect their scientists nd educationalists instead of illitrate politicians ?
Devadoss Eswar
Devadoss Eswar أشهر قبل
Hullo ! You have clearly spelt out the heart of a real human beyond the geographical borders ! Both of us are inherently good and mutually loving people !
Simplifying Food by Mary Damian
Idli powder :- ar-vids.com/video/%D9%81%D9%8A%D8%AF%D9%8A%D9%88-N1hUlvfL34k.html
rajiv shah
rajiv shah أشهر قبل
More people like you could unite india, end terrorism and ba a world economic superpower, by alas it is not so
nigil n
nigil n أشهر قبل
India respects scientist and intellectuals, but this is a plot set up by anti-nationals, that time when govt was weak, probabaly by the communist encroachers in Govt system to topple the govt systems itself. Read about RB Sreekumar and his bad intents lead to this. But now I'm current India, such incidents will not happen easily.
Debmalya Bhattacharya
Debmalya Bhattacharya أشهر قبل
@Warp Drive Not at all similar. He left Pakistan for constitutional and religious reasons. Nambi's case was different. Yes, both were not given their due honour. However, India did make amends later.
pakaboss007 2 أشهر قبل
Watched Rocketry yesterday. Feeling ashamed as Indian. I also declining career opportunities in US just to serve my country and pay all the hefty Tax but looks like it will just fill the pockets of our bloody Politicians. 😞
sahil pariani
sahil pariani 2 أشهر قبل
This is how the country pays back, specially when politics gets involved! There is no reward in India for patriotism! Very very sad! He deserved way more in this lifetime!!!
Routhu Vinaay
Routhu Vinaay سنوات قبل
Respected Sir, If you're in reach of this YOUR STORY animated. A heartful thanks and a deep sorry for that sorrowful days you underwent . You are great Sir, still you have a job in balance. Awakening of PATRIOTISM in the youth who are spending hours and hours on social media for ENTERTAINMENT and TIME PASS. Your story is heartening and pathetic, which exhibits THE MOST UPPER HAND involvement. BRING SCIENCE IN REACH TO THE COMMON GOVERNMENT SCHOOL STUDENTS " CATCH THE SCIENTISTS YOUNG" NAMBI NARAYAN SCIENCE TALENT CLUB. Educate this nation with your vast and valuable Experience This country needs you MY SIR.. A GREAT SALUTE TO THE REAL HERO...
Prashanth Puranik
Prashanth Puranik 8 أشهر قبل
It is sad that we treat our best minds with scant respect. He has every opportunity to lead a successful life abroad and this is how the nation paid him back. Kudos. At least he got justice after a long struggle but his suffering can never be compensated enough. If you are bright and have the opportunity to relocate to a country that respects sincerity and dedication in your work, please do yourself a favour and grab it with both hands.
Busy Bee
Busy Bee سنوات قبل
It was to US and not Pakistan. These politicians who are still in Kerala brought India 20 years back in the cryogenic race. US took or played a plot. 10:05 projects the police officers . Good job bisbo
Simplifying Food by Mary Damian
Idli powder :- ar-vids.com/video/%D9%81%D9%8A%D8%AF%D9%8A%D9%88-N1hUlvfL34k.html
TH G أشهر قبل
We should strong stratégie to avoid this. Our scientists work for nation. Police and others who created problem to Nambi, should screwed under their ass and hang them. I will do it in future if anyone screws our nation even if it is politician. Strong action safe life to our nation. What do you think?
DRAKE أشهر قبل
Religion is the best weapon used during political war
Jee 2 أشهر قبل
@Masochist Boy The case year is 1994 and earlier , tech now available at this time are not at all available openly to everybody , all are closely kept secrets , ISRO at nascent stage then depend on few dedicated scientists.
Storm Trooper
Storm Trooper 2 أشهر قبل
@ABHRA TALUKDER lol 😂 Delusional Indians Yeah keep thinking like that may be that will make you feel better
Rochit Shukla
Rochit Shukla سنوات قبل
Fantastically explained, without any exaggeration. 🔥🔥 The hardwork will surely payoff 🔥🔥
Bisbo سنوات قبل
Thank you!
Sooryadaz P
Sooryadaz P سنوات قبل
Dirty politics in Kerala 🔥 india lost more than 20 years ...
Alisha Mishra
Alisha Mishra سنوات قبل
Feeling so sad and helpless! A genius mind was destroyed. This happens when primary school dropouts run the country, without education and vision.
SYED SAHIR 2 أشهر قبل
This is how India's Development is Setback by Decades compared to other nations, who knows how many such corrupt activities people have done for their own profit and power and were not disclosed in public. My heartfelt respect for Nambi.
UPASANA سنوات قبل
It was not Nambi Narayanan' s career, but India's Cryogenic rocket technology development was spoiled by whoever behind the whole this so called espionage drama.
T P T أشهر قبل
@Gokul Raj Not correct. Read the comments by his co-accused scientist about him. (There was another scientist in the case along with Nambi). Also none of the other senior scientists at ISRO have supported his claim!!
Gokul Raj
Gokul Raj أشهر قبل
@T P T Your point is wrong brother.. It is true that many scientists are there in isro, but after Nambi's arrest, the scientists who were working on Cryogenic project were not ready to move forward in their research work. Because this case has grabbed a national attention. Manys scientist started moving towards other departments out of fear. This case caused a setback in Cryogenic engine development. And do you know that till today isro is using only the Vikas engine and not the cryogenic one.
T P T أشهر قبل
@Hitesh Anand There are several such leaders in ISRO!! Nambi became a team leader only because he was one of the senior most engineers. If he is not there then another senior engineer will take charge just like when one ISRO director retires a new person comes in his place, and no one is indispensable.
Hitesh Anand
Hitesh Anand أشهر قبل
@T P T And No team can work if There is no leader. And In case of Science development, The leader has major role. Team just do what they have been guided to. The leader has to use the brain.
Hitesh Anand
Hitesh Anand أشهر قبل
@T P T NOPE,The major scientific developments are done by few scientists only. Because in India, Scientists are scarce like Uranium. And as I mentioned before, Back in 80s,There were way too less scientists involved. And I just had mentioned how much isro was damaged because of absense of Nambi Narayana. What should have been done in 1994 was completed in 2005. That's the damage isro had.
abhishek unni
abhishek unni سنوات قبل
So proud to be a Keralite. FYI, many of the officers who were supposuto be held accountable retired honorably while holding very high Intelligence Bureau posts. 🤦
neel jain
neel jain سنوات قبل
Did Mr. Nambi really got justice? 25 years fight for such a honest person in supreme court itself says that he only got some money but Indian judiciary miserably failed. I am sorry to see the matter of fact and come to such conclusion. It is very easy to pamper oneself but difficult to accept that we as a nation on the ground of reality are day by day falling into dark.
Jinan Mk
Jinan Mk 2 أشهر قبل
The sordid story of the ISRO investigation has come into the spotlight again, after last week’s arrest of former Gujarat Director General of Police (DGP) R.B. Sreekumar, along with human rights campaigner Teesta Setalvad. The arrests followed the Supreme Court saying their allegations of state involvement in the 2002 Gujarat massacres were made “with ulterior motives”. For years now, Sreekumar’s supporters have cast him as an honest officer, committed to upholding his constitutional commitments to secularism and justice. To the victims of the ISRO case - key among them Princeton-educated aerospace engineer Nambi Narayanan - Sreekumar was a malign agent, who fabricated evidence to settle a personal vendetta. Also read: The ISRO spy case that became a potboiler of ‘sex, spies and rocket science’ The ISRO investigation The grandson of the eminent freedom fighter and journalist Balaramapuram G. Raman Pillai, Sreekumar was educated in Thiruvananthapuram, and joined the Indian Police Service (IPS) in 1971. He served as Superintendent of Police in seven districts - including Ahmedabad - and earned two President’s Police Medals. From all accounts, Sreekumar had a good record. Barring a 1986 case of alleged custodial violence, in which he was discharged, he faced no controversy. Five Kutch-border espionage cases that Sreekumar investigated drew the attention of then-Intelligence Bureau director H.A. Barari. A deputation to the Bureau followed in 1987. The ISRO case broke in 1994, when Sreekumar was, along with C.M. Ravindran, among two deputy directors serving at the Bureau’s Kerala station, under joint director Mathew John. Led by to-be Director General of Police Siby Mathews, Kerala investigators concluded that two Maldivian women, Mariam Rasheeda and Fousiya Hassan, engaged in a clandestine operation to steal Indian missile technology, together with K. Chandrasekhar, the representative of the Russian Glovkosmos space agency. The two women, police alleged, had seduced Narayanan and his deputy, D. Sasikumaran, to obtain access to drawings of India’s Vikas rocket engine and hundreds of other classified documents. Following a national furore, the case was transferred to the CBI - which soon determined the case didn’t have legs to stand on. The dates on which key conspiratorial meetings took place, for example, didn’t tally with the movements of the suspects and hotel records. Most importantly, there was nothing to show that any classified technology or documents had been stolen in the first place. In 1998, the Supreme Court ended the investigation on the basis of the CBI’s findings. The accused were released. Narayanan would later win a pathbreaking Rs 50 lakh in damages from the Kerala government. His career inside the Intelligence Bureau derailed by the scandal, Sreekumar returned to Gujarat in 2001. Following the riots in 2002, he emerged as a trenchant critic of now-Prime Minister Narendra Modi, submitting a series of affidavits to judicial and police investigators. Among other things, his affidavits claim the Gujarat authorities colluded in the anti-Muslim violence of 2002. The government’s supporters suggest that Sreekumar may have acted thus in a bid to pressure it to protect him against prosecution in the ISRO case - but no evidence has surfaced to support that claim. Sreekumar’s unresolved role From former Intelligence Bureau officer K.V. Thomas’s granular eyewitness account of the ISRO case, it’s clear much of the Kerala Police case was put together at the behest of the Intelligence Bureau. New Delhi-based intelligence officers, Thomas shows, played a leading part in putting together the story, tutoring the accused on the contents of videotaped confessional statements they were to make, and using pressure tactics like forcing Narayanan to strip to his underwear. Exactly how much of a role Sreekumar had in these developments - or the part played by his colleagues Ravindran and John - remain unknown. Thomas’ book contains suggestions that top officials in the Intelligence Bureau, like the late Moloy Dhar - who insisted the espionage case was true in his own book - may also have participated in crafting the conspiracy theory. The Bureau did conduct an internal inquiry, records seen by ThePrint show. The Bureau’s officers argued that, as members of a clandestine service with no legal standing, they had no role in Kerala’s decision to prosecute the suspects. Top officials, including the Intelligence Bureau’s director D.C. Pathak, flatly refused to speak with the CBI. For his part, Sreekumar told the CBI that he had only a peripheral role in the case because of other commitments, participating in the interrogation of Rasheeda for only two days. He also said he had no role in the making of the confessional videotapes and declined to offer an opinion on their contents. Kerala, similarly, took no action against investigators. In 2011, the state government dropped all charges against police, who had been accused of fabricating evidence. Following Sreekumar’s voluntary retirement, Mathews was appointed DGP. In 2013, the case flared up again, after now-Minister of State for External Affairs Meenakshi Lekhi accused Sreekumar of treason, arguing he had framed Narayanan at the behest of foreign agencies. Sreekumar responded by filing a defamation case, but the action was dropped after he chose not to pursue it. “I came to know that he was arrested today for keeping on fabricating stories and trying to sensationalise them,” Narayanan said after news of Sreekumar’s arrest broke. “It is exactly what he did in my case.” Earlier, Narayanan had told the CBI that Sreekumar may have acted from personal malice after the scientist failed to secure one of his relatives a job. He also alleged that Sreekumar participated in beating him in custody. For his part, Sreekumar has continued to insist that the investigation of the ISRO case was just, and claimed the CBI derailed a vital national-security investigation. Last year, the CBI filed an FIR naming 18 police and Intelligence Bureau officers - including Sreekumar - for allegedly framing suspects. There’s still no clarity, though, on why top Intelligence Bureau officials in New Delhi supported their Kerala station’s effort to fabricate evidence - and then sought to stonewall CBI investigators. Sreekumar might have had a personal score to settle, but that doesn’t explain the actions of the top Intelligence Bureau leadership. Is R.B. Sreekumar, then, a principled whistleblower, or malign agent? The full truth, sadly, might never be known. (Edited by Zinnia Ray Chaudhuri) Also read: ISRO spying case: CBI submits report in sealed cover in Supreme Court TAGSEspionageISRONambi Narayanan Previous article Simranjit Mann drops ‘Striving for Khalistan’ from Twitter bio after bypoll win, then restores it Next article We’re on right track: Powar RELATED ARTICLES Hamid Ansari being dragged into an imagined India-Pakistan espionage theory amounts to calumny ThePrint Team 14 July, 2022 Rocketry isn’t for Bollywood masala fans. It’s Madhavan’s show as ISRO’s Nambi Narayanan ISRO-IISc team develops prototype of bacteria-infused bricks for Martian, lunar soil Sandhya Ramesh 22 April, 2022 Substance of Print, Reach of Digital Contact us: feedback@theprint.in About Contact ValueAd Careers Terms of Use Privacy Policy Copyright © 2022 Printline Media Pvt. Ltd. All rights reserved.
Sameer Sharma
Sameer Sharma سنوات قبل
*You Just Nailed it,Keep it Up Politics Should be kept out from Atleast Sectors like Defence, Space research etc* 😍😀
Muneeb Khan
Muneeb Khan سنوات قبل
There must be justice for nambi. Our scientists don't deserve this. It should be an example for other not to mess with our tech guys. The police guys who framed nambi must be dragged to court and charged
Radhu Murlidhar
Radhu Murlidhar أشهر قبل
Do what the the Americans do - shoot first and then ask questions. Desh drohis don’t deserved to be tried in the court
cold fusion
cold fusion أشهر قبل
@just a random guy without a name but these are
Balasubramanian Subramanian
Balasubramanian Subramanian 2 أشهر قبل
@Gazpacho Police And it's pathetic that lots of criminals especially politicians are loitering free thanks to our slower-than-snail judicial system.
Siby Mathews
Siby Mathews 9 أشهر قبل
What is preventing CBI to file chargesheet?
Darshan Jain
Darshan Jain سنوات قبل
@Earth Planet study nicely and go to other country and live peacefully with your family
Learn English Tube
Learn English Tube سنوات قبل
This is one of my favourite channels!! lots of informative videos !! Thanks for sharing such videos !! Best wishes to you and your family !! Keep uploading !! Stay safe !! Thank you so much Lots of Love ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Abhijith Raman
Abhijith Raman سنوات قبل
So many questions have to be answered by Nambi Narayanan Sir before CBI now. it is now open for him to prove! 1. Why media create an image of a poor Tamil Brahmin? Even though he is not. 2. Why he submitted his Voluntary Retirement Application (VRS) on 01.11.1994 before he included in this case with a special request to waive the three months Notice Period? 3. What is the reason of the heavy Telephone Bill of one month in the year 1994 of more than Rs. 45000/- P.M. from the private phone attached to his residence by one Mr. Kuriyan Kalathil, Contractor? it is possible for a Scientist to do a private bussiness? Is it come under Official Secret Act 1923? 4. Why he is not telling the people that he was Reinstated in to Service, immediately and got Promotion and Retired from service on 31.12.2001 after getting all service benefits including the regularization of suspension period? Then what he lost actually? 5. What's his Contribution to get Padma Award.......Even more eligible Scientists are there.... Let him explain!!
Deyvanai Arumugam
Deyvanai Arumugam سنوات قبل
Thank you for making this video. The greatest and living legend Sir Nambi Narayanan.
Karthik N
Karthik N سنوات قبل
Such an inspiration man & the whole purpose of his life is lost to some pathetic petty politics. Meanwhile our great Indian ambition got trampled. ;( #JusticetoNambi bring those rouges under book
Minku arc
Minku arc سنوات قبل
Personnel gain is more powerful that our country! This is what this story proves. State politics can and bring any one down for their own gains. Media is just a puppet of the rich & powerful. Terrible terrible situations for deserving people like Mr Nambi, yet have high respect for him and salute him his patience and love for his country
Learn English Tube
Learn English Tube سنوات قبل
This is one of my favourite channels!! lots of informative videos !! Thanks for sharing such videos !! Best wishes to you and your family !! Keep uploading !! Stay safe !! Thank you so much Lots of Love ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
RK7 سنوات قبل
You know the state of your country when Veerappan's wife became a successful politician.
Avinash Poojary
Avinash Poojary سنوات قبل
Justice must be given to Mr.Nambi, after such cruel plots.
Avijit Goswami
Avijit Goswami سنوات قبل
It takes 25 years to take action against police ????? That's the problem ... You can change a politician in 5 years but what about police ????
Ashutosh Yadav
Ashutosh Yadav 4 أيام قبل
Join the police
Sai Prasad
Sai Prasad سنوات قبل
Very true. Our justice delivery system is a big joke.
kasi durai
kasi durai سنوات قبل
@CBI : Comment Bureau of Internet Well said bro
Avijit Goswami
Avijit Goswami سنوات قبل
@CBI : Comment Bureau of Internet exactly girls have to understand .. false cases actually weakend them ... When I try to save her, know one help me ... Know one beleive in a girl's statement ... That's harse truth
Avijit Goswami
Avijit Goswami سنوات قبل
@CBI : Comment Bureau of Internet I am trying to make human rights ngo .. the doctor target me because of the girl .. he want to be next baba ram rahim ... Now the same victim girl who fell love with me will give statement against me because her family sold him .. It's a web series ... Women freaky psychology is the main reason police and criminal use it ... Still I want to save the girl .. but after 2 year may be she completely become like gurmeet singh .. it's a psychological story ... Now people are so spinless I don't get proper people for my ngo ... Also I need ex justice, lawyer, ex ib , journalist ... Here all journalist is either spineless neither money minded .. After wrong treatment .. I also like half handicapped .. it's a game .. I want to punish him .. but I don't want girl name or pic exposed .... But here I can't find anyone .. I am weak at mobile , comuter ... I can't able to manage anyone out of my district .. I will apply for ngo with in some days .. but I need back up ... I can't beat him in court with out beating or exposed him publicly .... I need ex cbi type people .... Though have a new concept of modern ration social wellfare system, and land accure model .. if I get some popularity by sharing it .. then may some happen ... But from small cities I can't find any big people ... And in my town people are fear to support me , only because of the fraud had good relationship with police but mainly politician .... He want to open ashram or women shelter house ... Even I have to die , I will stop him .. but still I can manage a team ... Also I have physical pain that's why I am slow .. and also spend money on treatment ,it's another reason for I am late ... I can't able to pay big people ... Also my family was in fear , so I will leave family .. I stuck in every situation ... Old days .. I was happy intelligent guys ... Now night after night with physical pain and mental burning pain ... I am kinda stupid now ... My personal life is over ... But if I can't stop him .. in future many girls and patient will suffer, ... He is not that good villain .. but his spinless employee make him by fear .. I need team ... But I was sensitive about girls identity .. so media will be good or bad I don't know ... She is not my future ... She betrayed me by fear ... The last thing I want ... I want to save her from false marriage ..yahh false marriage .. and in future I will farewell her ... But now I am little bit aggressive .. I will demand compensation for destroying my health and carrier ... And for destroying personal life ... First time my life I dream every day to beat him broke him .... It's a web series ..... Now I find a answer ... Why good girl life finished by criminal minded guys and why boys can get a girl but never get or manage his true love ... Also I have many questions ... I never want anything from her .. I will forgive her ... But I just want to know exactly what happened internally in 2019
Ayon Arup Moitra
Ayon Arup Moitra 3 أشهر قبل
You finally named the culprits without any hesitation... Now tell me one thing, why only the police officials will be punished and not the politicians involved in the case specially someone like A K Anthony the celebrated congress leader. After all police officials were directed by the politicians only...
Road not taken
Road not taken سنوات قبل
Very very sad thing happened with him. :( Nambi sir is now 79 years old. Whatever years he has left, I wish he lives those years peacefully. And one thing Dr. Abdus Salam will not do cheap things like spying. He is a world renowned scientist.
Prabhjot Singh
Prabhjot Singh سنوات قبل
So, ego and politics can easily ruin someone's life
WrestleJamming سنوات قبل
Now when it' has come out wide n open there should be CBI enquiry. If this has caused a set back to the space research program then there should be taken stern steps against those guys involved.
Vikrant Sood
Vikrant Sood سنوات قبل
The Kerala police should be made accountable..and those responsible should be arrested..
MR Mr أشهر قبل
We citizens are responsible for tolerating this brutal act. Shameful on our society. Shree Ananthapadmanabhaswamy will only give remedy for this. Unable to imagine how our scientist and his family sustained. It’s a pain cannot define. As citizen We beg pardon before scientist and his family members.
Prajwal K P Bhat
Prajwal K P Bhat أشهر قبل
@pradeep kumar saying that as disgraceful is an understatement. Can't imagine what the women had to go through all those years.
TH G أشهر قبل
We should strong stratégie to avoid this. Our scientists work for nation. Police and others who created problem to Nambi, should screwed under their ass and hang them. I will do it in future if anyone screws our nation even if it is politician. Strong action safe life to our nation. What do you think?
Kill the culprit
Mahendra K
Mahendra K أشهر قبل
They should be SLAUGHTERED In public
White Lotus Meditation Music
We don’t need external forces to destroy our development, we can do it ourselves for petty gains.
Arjun Raghav A
Arjun Raghav A أشهر قبل
It's so scary to be in Kerala after seeing this, god if anything can happen to ISRO scientists, how common ppl will get protection. Looks like that regime of Kerala government destroyed our country's progress and sole reason for intellectuals flooding to USA etc leaving India
George Kurian
George Kurian أشهر قبل
Lol. No wonder ISRO’s largest pool of scientists and engineers continue to study, research and work in its centres and space university in Trivandrum.
mrsv singh
mrsv singh سنوات قبل
I have no words to describe how my heart bleeds..may the culprits rot in hell for eternity
DIY Bill
DIY Bill سنوات قبل
We are proud of ISRO and it’s previous and current team.
Jayanth Reddy
Jayanth Reddy سنوات قبل
Waiting for Madhavan sir's "Rocketry" which focuses on his life. Hope it releases soon.
Supriya Tetali
Supriya Tetali أشهر قبل
@Vamsh it released
TH G أشهر قبل
We should strong stratégie to avoid this. Our scientists work for nation. Police and others who created problem to Nambi, should screwed under their ass and hang them. I will do it in future if anyone screws our nation even if it is politician. Strong action safe life to our nation. What do you think?
Creater أشهر قبل
it's released in amazon prime video
Neha Pandey
Neha Pandey 2 أشهر قبل
Chetana Sai
Chetana Sai 2 أشهر قبل
@Raghavenderan Jagannathan But Sir means Slave I Remain, right
Karthik أشهر قبل
Justice for Nampi Sir. 💚
ullianove أشهر قبل
...no words...no wonder why most of the family in Kerala are sending their children to other countries for study and job. And that's why countries like USA are growing. Life of a genius put in jail just for political role.
Viraaj Makwana
Viraaj Makwana 8 أشهر قبل
The main officer behind this was former DGP SIBY MATHEWS. He should be brought to justice and reveal the names of people with whom he planned this.
Dr.Prasoon Shrivastava
Dr.Prasoon Shrivastava 7 أيام قبل
Felt really sorry for what a great scientist had to go through just for a greedy political gain of someone. Its high time we need to make people (Police personal and political leader) accountable, who are responsible for this act. Seize their belongings and pay to the patriotic scientist. Offcourse we cannot compensate for the loss to our country. Punishment should bring shivers to the spines of corrupt persons, only then such cases can be stopped.
Vishnu Vm
Vishnu Vm سنوات قبل
Nice presentation... Thanks to open up this incidence to everyone
Aranya Prakash
Aranya Prakash سنوات قبل
Let's be fair if something like this happen to me I would rather leave the country and go to us and work with NASA means look how easy it is to say sorry after doing all this
Brad Young
Brad Young سنوات قبل
Shame on the scientists who made him work on desk ! What kind of scientists are they who are not able to see the truth of evidences. Who can't understand pain of a learned soul that put all his life on one of the highest pursuits as a human being. Hence proved, a few worms can definitely put a saint to death. And the spineless public will always cheer for the crook.
PARTH PATEL سنوات قبل
This happens in the state of 100% educated people. He refuses nasa offer how he can chit India Not only nabi sir so many isro scientists killed during Congress government
Kuroki 2 أشهر قبل
​@The Indian Communist You just described the communists in Kerala with perfection
@AsmitaSinha سنوات قبل
@God is in control I am an full fledged Indian by birth. And I have heard and read countless times about how Arrogant Kerelites literally reject anything our govt does. And how Horribly they treat North Indians and Hindus. My father got a posting in Kerela , but he returned only after 3 months. Almost every single time he described how Horribly North Indians are treated there😠😠. He said he didn't felt like he was in India at all. INSTEAD OF SHOUTING AT ME YOU SHOULD DO SOME RESEARCH ABOUT HOW MUCH KERELITES HATE WE NORTH INDIANS, INDIAN GOVT , HINDUS😠😠😠😠
God is in control
God is in control سنوات قبل
@@AsmitaSinha ....who are you to say that! You are a immigrant from afganistan. U are the one must leave here
𝗮(𝗲)𝘀𝘁 𝗛𝘂𝗺𝗮𝗻
Ravindran Seshadri
Ravindran Seshadri 2 أشهر قبل
This is a great movie. Everyone should watch. Great great job Madhavan. My heart goes for the great Nambi Narayanan!! Surya, sharukh did a splendid job. Madhavan - No question. - Magnificent performance. Overall it was a perfect package!!
Yawee Arts & Crafts
Yawee Arts & Crafts سنوات قبل
Thank you for bringing out this story!
Shory Aakriti
Shory Aakriti سنوات قبل
It had been better for him to take job opportunity at nasa ....See that's why most of the youth of India doesn't like to serve in our country because of the dirty politics and corrupt media.
HARISH SAI.D 2 سنوات قبل
Yeah even my son has great knowledge in space But he wants to go to NASA
Apoorva Gupta
Apoorva Gupta سنوات قبل
Can we give back the respect to Nambi Narayanan. His career got destroyed because of this .. this is how we treat people who left high paying jobs for their motherland.
The case could not have taken its blown out proportions without media trials. Same happened in SSR case any many more. There should be a law to prevent media from giving verdict themselves for an undertrial case
Ravindra Sinha
Ravindra Sinha سنوات قبل
It is obvious that Congress party members were involved in this scandal. Case must be handed over to NIA
Sandeep Mukherjee
Sandeep Mukherjee سنوات قبل
Awesome presentation....you deserve all praise
vinoo koshy
vinoo koshy أشهر قبل
so sad and shameful on the part of those who put an end to this genius 's future and also Indian Space missions
Kousik v
Kousik v أشهر قبل
It's a big thing that you ve taken the interest to bring this out. There would be heaps of votes from the public if it was some cine actress or jallikattu etc. Who would care for this poor man??
Jayachandran R
Jayachandran R سنوات قبل
I was a kid back then, very faintly i remember him being taken to court. Thanks for putting up the details as i was not so keen on watching the movie. Why are some people of our country always sold out to money and sex. At least Nambi sir survived, thinking of Sushanth Singh still brings sadness on my face.
Arockiya Raj Williams
Arockiya Raj Williams 2 أشهر قبل
Actually after se the rocketry movie only i came to know about this poor real incident that shouldn't be happened for a patriotic scientist.
Rogue&Eldritch سنوات قبل
another example to tell your parents why foreign education leading to settling down there is a good thing. Getting into IIT/IIM is so tough, imagine what it will be like to your children. but first you need a decent paying job and time to raise family.
as your classmate
as your classmate سنوات قبل
Mr. Nabinarayanan, in his earlier report to the court, said, "It is clear that Nabinarayanan did not have any custodial torture as demonstrated by the bisbo. These allegations are CBi allegations to entrap IB and state policing." The Supreme Court is not ready to accept the day-to-day evidence of the state police and the IB. The truth is that if the officer who investigated the case is given a remand, then the courts have acquitted the accused in the past. The court did not consider it necessary to investigate.
Ag Sitaraman
Ag Sitaraman 2 أشهر قبل
This point has bren addressed properly.where is the record of interogation of mr.nambinarayan bypilice and IB .dont defend the indefensible.
chaitanya سنوات قبل
People who are going to abroad and settling there are doing correct thing.
Pavani أشهر قبل
Watching the movie left me so anguish. If Mr. Nambi Narayan was left alone, am sure India today would have been way too ahead in space research! We have let our own jewel get mugged and torture by imposing stupid baseless allegations while other countries progressed ahead in space!
Gokulc Cholapallil
Gokulc Cholapallil سنوات قبل
Nambi narayan is not a "scientist" he is only a "technocrat" all people working in ISRO is not scientist
Abhishek Mishra
Abhishek Mishra سنوات قبل
Thank you bro for this real life story.
Ian Stobie
Ian Stobie أشهر قبل
Excellent report, although obviously years late! CBI comes out of it well - established facts quickly once they got involved in the case, and reported fairly. Then huge long delay before any justice! And eventually a few local cops get blamed, while evil politicians get off free. And Indian national space effort suffers as side effect of sordid Kerala political smear campaign. Useless journalists who failed to check the original stories of police and politicians at the time also come out of it badly, but probably were intimidated or told what to say by owners, or just happy to run with any sensational story, true or not. It took a long time for true story to come out from CBI and better journalists. Best wishes to ISRO 🚀🚀🚀 for pushing through this kind of interference and still getting the job done. Came across this video after watching launch of a new ISRO rocket for commercial payloads.
Rakesh Kumar
Rakesh Kumar 2 أشهر قبل
Justice must be served 👍
Satyadeep K
Satyadeep K سنوات قبل
“I want to serve my country….”🥲
Sadanandam Alugoju
Sadanandam Alugoju 2 أشهر قبل
Some one who says I am Hindu, Is it a sin to be Hindu can never be a true scientist.
Satyam Yadav
Satyam Yadav 3 أشهر قبل
I'm ashamed what our government did with this scientist. He could be another APJ Abdul Kalam, but what he got is shameful.
Abhiraj Arora
Abhiraj Arora سنوات قبل
I love how the State Of Kerala dropped charges against the police officers who falsely implicated Mr. Narayan. That mleccha, Sybi Matthews went on to become Chief Information Commissioner of Kerala. Truly God's own country. What a wonderful police system of the superior Mallus. If it hadn't been for the Supreme Court of India, these sh*ts would have walked free.
FOX never tell LIES
FOX never tell LIES 2 أشهر قبل
@Gavaskar Reddy ISRO Espionage Case was a political drama, masterminded by rivals of K.Karunakaran,from his own Congress Party. Mainly 2 persons were severely affected by this Espionage case- K. Karunakaran & NambiNarayanan.
Gavaskar Reddy
Gavaskar Reddy 2 أشهر قبل
Actually Nambi was a victim of Hinduphobia. Believe it or not.
Diya سنوات قبل
back in the days kerala politics was more of this drama.. even now its not so better
Vishnu Vm
Vishnu Vm سنوات قبل
True... Political dramas in kerala makes many lives suffer on that time.
Raghavenderan Jagannathan
Raghavenderan Jagannathan سنوات قبل
Seriously I am imagining nambi sirs mental status then .... as a fellow indian feeling ashamed ... had he been in that project I think we would have been well ahead in cryogenic engines and its successors by now ... God bless india ..
hareesh p
hareesh p 2 أشهر قبل
Saw his biopic Rocketry The Nambi effect. Great man 👏👏👏
All those who were involved in the investigation of this case must be arrested & penalised
thejaswini shankar
thejaswini shankar سنوات قبل
Justice delayed is justice denied.. Already enough damage has made.. A young guy lost his career and at this old age he got justice.. Shame on indian justice system.
SIDEMEN CHARITY MATCH 2022 (Goals & Highlights)
عدد المشاهدات 7 424 657
I built a WORKING LEGO Movie Theater... 🍿
عدد المشاهدات 352 592
How was England formed?
عدد المشاهدات 9 200 000
SIDEMEN CHARITY MATCH 2022 (Goals & Highlights)
عدد المشاهدات 7 424 657